News

Actions

Judge orders farmer to stop using eggshells as fertilizer

Strong smell drove neighbors away
Posted

BETHEL, N.Y. (AP) — A judge has ordered an upstate New York farmer to stop using eggshells as fertilizer after neighboring businesses complained the smell and clouds of flies drove away customers.

The Times Herald-Record of Middletown reports Peter Hofstee has been applying crushed eggshells to his hay fields in the Sullivan County town of Bethel since his usual fertilizer of liquid duck manure was cut off by the supplier last summer.

The owners of a restaurant and a distilling company adjacent to the fields took Hofstee to court, saying the rotting eggshells caused an unbearable stench and served as a source of fly larvae.

A state Supreme Court judge ordered the farmer to remove his eggshell stockpiles and rid his fields of fly larvae.

Hofstee says the ruling will put him out of business.

,

Weather

Daily Forecast

View Hourly Forecast

Day

Conditions

HI / LO

Precip

Monday

12/29/2025

Partly Cloudy

-° / 40°

6%

Tuesday

12/30/2025

Cloudy

54° / 45°

24%

Wednesday

12/31/2025

Rain

52° / 49°

72%

Thursday

01/01/2026

Partly Cloudy

59° / 49°

6%

Friday

01/02/2026

Showers

64° / 54°

46%

Saturday

01/03/2026

Cloudy

58° / 49°

24%

Sunday

01/04/2026

Mostly Cloudy

59° / 46°

6%

Monday

01/05/2026

Partly Cloudy

57° / 46°

24%